Elder Mediation
By MARILYN SOLTIS
Nothing brings out the skeletons in the family closet like addressing
the legal, medical, financial, social and family issues of an aging
parent. Childhood favoritism, expectations of inheritance, and
dissolution of property can cause a schism in the closest of
siblings. It’s a growing problem. By 2030 the number of
older people (over 65) is expected to increase to over 70 million, or
nearly 20 percent of the population.
The answer could be elder mediation, a burgeoning field where
complex eldercare issues are addressed by a specialist in elder
mediation who can advance the process of conflict resolution without
advocating for one particular party. In fact, the goal is to ultimately
find a common ground in which all parties feel their concerns have been
addressed and seriously considered. Needs, rather than positions, are
the focus.
Jerald Kessler, Mediator/Attorney, based in Libertyville says that
elder mediation is a growing field partly because of the aging
population and the expense of litigation. “Legal remedies are hard to
calibrate,” he says. Going to court is a fairly drastic step.
He says that often a situation needing mediation arises when the
elderly person is reluctant to surrender independence in any form and
resists efforts to limit mobility like driving and living independently.
A conversation unfolds. Usually, family members express concern and
worry and offer options like alternative transportation, assistance in
various daily functions, and a discussion of other living situations.
Mediation is helpful when there is an impasse—the children are not
on the same page but he cautions that “every family is different.”
“There’s a basic process. Theoretically, gather information,
identify specific issues, brainstorm options and discuss acceptable
options and come to an agreement.” Conflict resolution skills rather
than adversarial skills are at work here. “Attorneys who mediate are not
going to give legal advice—they are there solely as mediators,” says
Kessler.
“The key is to have a mediator who can alter that model to the
specific situation. Artistry is involved. A lot of training is involved.
The last thing the family needs is a lawsuit. A lawsuit is a crude
implement for addressing issues that come up. Legal remedies are not
finely tuned. It’s all about process. You can come up with individually
tailored outcomes as opposed to having it imposed through the court,”
says Kessler.
People in all sorts of professions mediate—it is not regulated in
Illinois. There are circuit-by-circuit certifications for court-ordered
mediation but the quality is minimal, according to Kessler.
“Consumers have to do their homework. A lot of mediators have
minimal introductory training. It presents a challenge to the
profession.”
"More and more people want mediation—so they are becoming educated
about it. Mediation minimizes legal expense and preserves family
relationships,” says Kessler.
Bill Wilson, of the Wilson & Wilson Law Offices, Center for
Estate Planning and Elder Law, in LaGrange says elder law disputes are “like a divorce with more characters involved.”
He says the issues usually involve money and who is going to be the
guardian. The scenario usually involves someone who isn’t getting what
he expected—nothing or less than
expected.
“Money becomes a symbol for affection so it could be a small or
really large amount. If they need another lawyer it’s usually a large
amount because attorney fees are too high for a small estate,” he says.
Wilson says most issues can be resolved, but sometimes he sends
people to an attorney who specializes in mediation if there will be a
conflict of interest in reaching a settlement.
He says conflict often arises when the children of the first
marriage are concerned about the parent’s assets after the parent has
remarried. Often, when someone draws up a will or trust there is a child
who has not seen the person, talked in years or has stolen money. There
are many areas of bad blood. “It has all the emotions and baggage of
childhood. Sometimes spouses get in on it, telling their spouses they
should get money,” says Wilson.
The stakes are higher than ever before. “The amount of money being
shifted to and from the boomers is the greatest amount of money ever
being transferred. A lot of people want that money so there is a lot of
litigation. Mediation is cheaper than going to full trial,” says Wilson.
More sources for eldercare mediation are available today like
Mediate.com,
eldermediators.com,
and the
National Eldercare Mediator Network. Not only can you find a
wealth of information on the subject but there are state-by-state
directories.
Eldercare mediation is a growing industry of elder care mediators with various backgrounds and levels of training.
Mediation and Special Needs AttorneysAccording to the National Association of Elder Law Attorneys
(NAELA), Elder and Special Needs Attorneys are experts in key areas
including:
-
Estate Planning and Probate
- Estate and Gift Planning
-
Guardianship/Conservatorship
-
Medicaid
- Medicare
-
Entitlement Programs
-
Retirement Benefits
-
Age Discrimination
-
Elder Abuse/Neglect
-
Housing
-
Long Term Care Financing
-
Medical Decision Making
-
Disability Planning
- Insurance
Eldercare Mediators say that their specialties include:
-
Quality of Life
-
Housing
-
Car Keys, Driving and Transportation (limitations on driving,
testing, transportation to medical appointments, friends, social events
and church).
- Caregiving (division of duties, relief for caregivers, level of
care needed, planning vacations for parents and caregivers)
- Financial Decisions
- Working through Family Fights (improving sibling relationships, learning communication skills, and working as a team)
- Geriatric Assessment
- Wills, Trusts and Estates (planning, distribution of assets, and resolution of family disputes)
- Division or Sale of Farms, Business and Property
- Powers of Attorney and Avoiding Guardianship
- Health Care Decisions
- Emergency Decisions
- Planning Ahead for End of Life Decisions (funeral planning and
Advanced Directives, Living Wills/Life Prolongation, organ donation
preference, appointment of health care representatives)
- Resident injury, level of care, and Wrongful Death
Published: October 13, 2012
Issue: November 2012 Issue